KOCHU VARTHAMANAM: Damn The Dam
This is an appeal to everybody out there to please refrain from inciting ugly emotions or fanning the fires of passion or sowing divisive thoughts. For Remitha Satheesh, the issue hits very close home.
On Nov 27, 2011
|
Looks like the next Jasmine Revolution is brewing, with its ripples felt all across the social media. Pardon me… did I say ripples. I think the choice of a word like Tsunami would be better suited here. After all, the subject here is water and the emotions behind the issue are welling up like a veritable tsunami.
A look at the two sides heading for a face off: Two states, interwoven through millennia by common roots. Two languages, one believed to be the mother of the other. Two people, interlinked by an easy exchange of culture. Two societies on the verge of being divided by a wall of water. Two governments choosing to feign impotence till things go too far. Water like its co-element Fire is a double-edged sword. Giving and taking life is part of what it does. When taking life is an act of Nature, we accept it. Chiefly because we are powerless in the face of Nature’s fury. But when the cause is man made, it is unacceptable. Whether the loss is precipitated by a broken dam flooding lands due to human negligence or brother killing brother over the issue of water. The loss if it comes, is heavy for both sides. One side will lose its valuable supply of water resulting in damage to crops, a big blow to agriculture. As for the other side, it is lives that will be lost. And not in small numbers. When you tally the losses, the balance sheet points to a heavier loss for the latter. Human lives account for more than crops any day. The facts are all out there for those looking for them. The pros and cons, the amount of damage that can be caused by the unleashed waters, the Science and the Math behind it and more importantly, the emotions riding high on those waves… everything is out there, spreading faster than a flash flood. It is the emotions that I am worried about. Like I said earlier, the bond between a Tamil and a Malayali is much closer than that between two people belonging to two other languages. They have lived in peace, side by side, most amicably, easily exchanging cultures. The reason for this is the fact that the languages are so similar to each other. With a slight attempt, one can easily understand the other, unlike trying to learn another language. So despite the snide remarks and stereotypical comments that both pass at each other and the ‘Pandi’ and ‘Kanji’ taunts, the bonds somehow run deep. A relationship more akin to indulgent sibling rivalry rather than real, hardcore rivalry or vengefulness. The Tamil is known to be a creature of emotions unlike the more stoic Malayali. Everything on the Eastern side of the Ghats is slightly over the top- colours, movies, feelings, celebrations, mourning, art, literature, the very language… everything goes a couple of notches higher than the understatements and subtleties more popular on this side of the border. For the same reason, their actions don’t just speak louder than their words, they practically scream at you. That is why you find people committing self-immolation when a beloved leader dies, building temples to a favorite film star or drawing out weapons when the honour of a community is threatened. But they are also unbeatable when it comes to hospitality and showering you with love. The Mallu on the other hand is also unbeatable when it comes to opening
up his arms and welcoming to his land anyone who comes there in the name
of trade or tourism. He also has no qualms about appreciating the
culture or art of a non-Malayali with equal gusto. If you doubt that
statement, just take a look at the movies running to full houses in
theaters in Kerala and make a list. How many Malayalam movies do you
find on your list? (and no, we are not taking into account a certain
movie by a certain person whose skin is being studied to develop the
latest in bullet proof technology).
And nobody can laugh at himself louder than a Malayali. His
self-deprecating humor is incomparable as is his good-natured way of taking
the jokes ‘simbly’ flying around.
|
And that is why I am so worried that with an issue like this, emotions
are bound to run high and I hope people will not fan the flames but
rather look for a solution that can be acceptable to both. This is not
the time to indulge in panic triggered irrational actions. We as a
nation have opened the eyes of the world to peaceful protests. Let’s put
to good use what we have taught the world.
This is an appeal to everybody out there to please refrain from inciting ugly emotions or fanning the fires of passion or sowing divisive thoughts. If you have something sensible about the issue to share, do put it up on the walls of your social platforms by all means. On the other hand, if what you have to say carries seeds of hate and violence, please stop. Blood IS thicker than water. I say this to both sides. Before you share anything across your social networks, take a look at your list of ‘Friends’. How many are from the other side of the border? Is the bond you share with them weak enough to be broken over this issue? Or is it not worth saving? Candlelight vigils/signature campaigns/appealing to one’s better sense and
humanity-OK.
Hate campaigns/banning movies/boycotting theaters/snide remarks-Not OK. And my dear fellow Malayalis, I do realize how high the stakes are on your side of the border. You might think that boycotting Tamil films might be a good idea. What if they decide to halt all the ‘pandi lorries’ bringing your food and other essential commodities on that side of the border? And you might also want to consider the safety of the thousands of youngsters gearing up to be engineers/Doctors/Business Honchos etc. on that side. So please, “SamyamanmPalikkoo!” And my dear fellow Tamils, please stop being led by scheming politicians whose only concern is lining their pockets and that of their next 7 generations. They might be people shorn of all human values; but you are not. Now is the time to show the world the shining qualities of the proud Tamil and what makes him special. You can show solidarity with your brothers across the border and prove to everyone that the bonds tying Man to Man cannot be broken by cheap politics or a few hundred feet of water. Act now and show that famous ‘ThamizhPanpadu’ you are known for. Need I remind you of the words of KaniyanPoonkundranar…? ‘Yaadhumoore; Yaavarumkelir’ (that would translate as, the world is my hometown and all men are my kin) Lets us not politicize the issue; instead, let good sense and humanity prevail!
Remitha Satheesh
A
home maker living the 'easy life' in the US of A, juggling her time
cooking, cleaning, chauffeuring and playing maid. In between, she nurses
fanciful delusions of being the next JK Rowling and tries to 'write'.
Previously In
Kochu Varthamanam:
|
Comments
I think both communities are evolved enough to sit down and sort things out amicably. Unlike many other groups who will be more than trigger happy to scuttle progress. Great write as usual Remitha! I loved the bullet proof skin bit. hehe
Prathap Suthan,
on Nov 27, 2011 08:53:40 AM
Reading your articles and eating a sweet (I simply love both) are things I do the same way. Slowly, savouring each line/ bite! 'Simbly" enjoyable..the way you write, and then topics are also serious ones. And most of the times I do find myself shaking my head 'yes. yes' to the points you mention!
Shivaja ...... Remitha Fan:),
on Nov 27, 2011 12:15:51 PM
A socially relevant article narrated in the humblest and easiest of ways, truly deserving to be titled 'Kochu Vartmanam'. Well written Remitha
Fole Kwartersen,
on Nov 28, 2011 04:28:27 AM
Hi Remitha,
I am not sure, how you would feel if someone made fun of you as a person in an unrelated weblog, without reading or qouting your writings. Please avoid personal gags, as this guy has already been abused so much in so little time. Not all are belessed with articulatory skills as you are, but all voices are divine in the eyes of nature/creator.
Good timely piece on spreading a relevant message.
Hemant,
on Nov 28, 2011 02:20:58 PM
Remitha, certain selected words here do not go well with the subject and standards of the article.contd comments...on the same subject...I was just waiting to see this article come in yentha.com to respond.I just have a simple question to ask.At present everybody is just concentrating towards the achievement of getting a new dam.All well done cabinet ministers and top govt leaders agree to it. Now this will take another two years maybe to complete this project.What guaranttee is there that nothing would happen in between this period. So FIRST see how this can prevent a disaster even before going for a new dam.SECOND...the present Dam which was constructed 116yrs before the strength and quality of it, will the new one be equally having the quality of it with the corrupt contractors and politicians to this issue. I just cant even think of it.Only God can save us.
Joe Abraham,
on Nov 29, 2011 04:19:42 PM
Prathap, Shivaja, Hemanth, Joe, thank you for dropping by. Appreciate all your comments and concerns.
Remitha Satheesh,
on Nov 29, 2011 10:40:54 PM
Things are now going from bad to worse.Politicing the issue is due to fishing out of troubled water.The article is thought provoking,but who cares and who reads?
Isac Santhakunar,
on Dec 06, 2011 12:15:58 PM
Politicians have flared up the issue. Reports say Dam can withstand earthquake up to scale 6.8. Sesimologists say that there is no likelihood of earthquake beyond 3.8 in the region.. IMD has never reported a earthquake in the region beyond 3.6. in the past 150 years. Then why this sudden fear psychosis? Chandy is playing a loosing game on an uneven ground with Jayalaitha to make her stronger….My cynical mind suspects a connivance between Chandy and Jayalaitha…poor citizens of both sides will bear the brunt. .
Siva C,
on Dec 06, 2011 03:20:05 PM
Politicians have flared up the issue. Reports say Dam can withstand earthquake up to scale 6.8. Sesimologists say that there is no likelihood of earthquake beyond 3.8 in the region… IMD has never reported a earthquake in the region beyond 3.6in the past 150 years… Then why this sudden fear psychosis? Chandy is playing a loosing game on an uneven ground with Jayalaitha to make her stronger….My cynical mind suspects a connivance between Chandy and Jayalaitha…poor citizens of both sides will bear the brunt. .
Siva C,
on Dec 06, 2011 03:22:34 PM
Dear brother Siva C.,
You claim that no earthquakes beyond 4.6 have been recorded in Kerala since the last 106 years....can I know why you are in love with 4.6? Do take a look at the following.....
07 June 1988 - Kalar-Idukki area, Kerala, Ms 4.5 (13).
09.80 N, 77.20 E (3), OT=03:05:48 UTC (13)
There were three events recorded within a 24-hour period. The largest was a magnitude 4.5, followed by a Ms 4.2 (3) the same day at 15:24:48 UTC (13) and a Ms 3.5 (3) on 08 June at 03:03:34 UTC (13). The fault plane solution indicates a strike-slip mechanism (3). This event was felt in the Idukki area of Kerala. The epicentre is located in the Cardamom Hills along the border with Tamil Nadu.
12 December 2000 - Idukki-Painavu area, Kerala, Mw 4.6
09.824 N, 76.763 E, D=010.0 kms, OT=01:23:58 UTC
A light earthquake struck the Idukki region in Kerala, India, on 12 December 2000 at 06:53 AM local time resulting in some damage to property in parts of central Kerala. It had a magnitude of Mw=4.7 and was felt for close to 40-seconds in parts of the states of Kerala and Tamil Nadu.
07 January 2001 - Idukki-Painavu area, Kerala, Mw 4.7
09.801 N, 76.548 E, D=025.4 kms, OT=02:55:59 UTC
A light earthquake struck the Kottayam region in Kerala, India, on 7 January 2001 at 08:25 AM local time resulting in two deaths and some damage to property in parts of central Kerala. It had a magnitude of Mw=4.6 and was felt for close to 27-seconds in parts of the states of Kerala and Tamil Nadu.
http://asc-india.org/seismi/seis-keralak.htm
The latest one was at 13 kms East of Erattupetta (Kottayam) - richter scale 3.2 on 25th Nov 11, while the earlier one was at Kallar near Idukki (3.1) on 18th Nov 11
Are you an expert in earthquakes and dams to conclude that nothing will shake Mullaperiyar dam? Can you please take a trip to Idukki area and talk to the ones (both Tamilians and Keralites) who live in fear of their lives?
Yes.. politicians are playing games.. but please do not join the politicians at this juncture.
Happy Kitten,
on Dec 08, 2011 02:12:21 PM
Sorry for the typo.. Siva says.. no earthquakes beyond 3.6....
and IDB has given the following SEISMICITY MAP
which gives a 6- 6.9 in Kerala.. please check it out..
http://www.imd.gov.in/section/seismo/static/seismicity-map.htm
Happy Kitten,
on Dec 08, 2011 02:57:14 PM
Thanks for your Link which is quite informative….My question is why this SUDEN fear psychosis? Who is responsible ? Even if the Dam is to be relocated , it would take not less than 3-5 years .Do you want the people to live in perceived fear for so long? ...For time being,the wise thing would be to protect and strengthen the existing structure and relieve the people from fear...Relacation of the dam can be discussed on the basis of Science ,not on sentiments.. Did you check up the ground on which Supreme Court decided in favour of Tamil Nadu to increase the water level to 142 feet ?... I am not supporting the indifferent stand of TN today.. At the same time I would strongly say that Kerala politicians lack commitment , clarity and coherence on the issue..they pretend to be united... .None of the Kerala politicians believes that DAM would burst….. So is Jayalalitha.....I pray for the peaceful living ofIdukki Dist people.
Siva C,
on Dec 10, 2011 07:16:06 PM
The plea for a new dam has intensified because of the recent temors.. more than 20 in the last 9 months.
The request is not only for a new dam but also to reduce the water level to 120. This I assume is a safe level.
The recent uproar is not because of the politicians..in fact they were forced to join the common man.
Besides, how long do you expect a dam to survive?
If water is the only issue for TN, then Kerala has never denied the same.. so what is the real issue?
A new dam can be contructed with all safety measures... and it will be in favor of TN if they take the initiative.
After all, the Keralites have no regard for water..(taken for granted).... it might as well be given to those who will make good use of it.
Happy Kitten,
on Dec 12, 2011 05:09:46 PM
Of course reducing the water level to 120ft for next 3 months in the existing dam is a possible step to defuse the tension(but this is not the solution to the problem).Jayalaitha can do it as a gesture till the committee comes out with the report . But... Construction of a new dam is not as easy as you say.This option is not going to be suggested by experts and Supreme Court for the same reason you cited above(tremor).Neutral experts can find out the course of water flow in the event of the dam burst and suggest measures to protect propoerty and people.I find some sense in what TN PWD officials say and Kerala Attorney General's submission to High court.
Siva C,
on Dec 13, 2011 12:27:15 AM
Siva, can you please elaborate... since I do not find any sense in AG's submission to the court..
and why shouldn't SC take into account the recent tremors? Are our renowned judges above nature? Have they ever predicted earth quakes?
TN can do much more to make use of the rain water by contructing more storage tanks and such facilities since availability of land is not an issue unlike Kerala. In this way the extra rain water which otherwise will flow into the sea will not be wasted.. this will also let the dam maintain a safe height. World over, dams are being constructed with lesser heights since it is better... one is not sure if the dams (plus the heavy rains) are the cause of the recent tremors.
but then TN is also generating power out of Mullaperiyar dam.. even if they are not citing this openly.. it is a known fact. The resistance from TN is mainly due to the fear that existing conditions may change if a new dam is built. This is one reason why the TN MP's have come up with the most idiotic demands of all.... that Idukki be added to TN!
A silly solution to a problem which needs to be sorted out mutually across the table.. instead of refusing to even discuss..
And the so called govt. at the center is as usual silent...
Happy Kitten,
on Dec 13, 2011 01:04:53 PM
We need to wait for the Expert Committee report to assess the impact of latest tremors on the Dam.If your contention is correct, the judgement will be different from the one pronounced few years ago.. I wonder why national TV channels and Newspapers don't talk about this issue seriously. They report it as a routine political tug of war... There is one Dam near Trichy ( Kallanai)which is 2000 Years old.
Siva C,
on Dec 13, 2011 10:07:03 PM
Yes, there are dams older than Mullaperiyar and there are dams that have withstood strong earthquakes (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koyna_Dam). We have them in India itself but they are not the same as Mullaperiyar.
Since you mentioned Kallanai; it is made of unhewn stone (300 meter long, 20 meter wide, and 4.5 meter high), while Mullaperiyar (365.7 meter long and 53.6 meter high ) is built using lime and surkhi mortar (A mixture of sugar and Calcium oxide)
http://arno.unimaas.nl/show.cgi?fid=14861
From yesterday’s SC verdict, it is clear that even the Judges have sensed the fear of Kerala.
Think it is time TN took heed of the genuine request of those in Kerala and try to work out a solution.
Happy Kitten,
on Dec 14, 2011 03:32:10 PM
Yesterday’s observation of Supreme Court is ...
"If there would have been an emergency situation, the committee would have taken up the matter or brought it to our notice. In the absence of either, we believe the situation is not grave as being projected," the judges said.(NDTV report)
See...State is a man made boundary ..Human life is precious wherever it is.TN & Kerala are in the same region and in fact it was ruled by the same Chera dynasty of western Tamil nadu with Karur( Kodungaiyur) as the capital till 12th Century. There are similarities in Culture, language,beliefs, behaviour. These similarities would be strikingly visible when you see them together in an alien land . ...Let us not look at this issue as a dispute between two states. This is an issue concerning the livelihood of 5 million Indians living in TN and the life of another 5 million Indians living in Kerala. Let us have faith in Supreme Court and its Committee and wait for an amicable solution. Above all, Let us all hope that the Creator wouldn’t let us down.
Siva C,
on Dec 14, 2011 06:19:04 PM
Nice article
SH,
on Dec 19, 2011 01:38:59 PM
Pls give us more columns like Kochuvarthamanam
HVS,
on Dec 19, 2011 01:44:12 PM
What is this finally coming to? The 'damn' issue is slowly getting out of hand ... someone said vegetables? Let's grow them!
Starving Malayalee,
on Dec 19, 2011 02:06:21 PM
Siva, yes one can wait (eternally?) for the court to settle this issue even though the court itself indicated that disputes between states have never been settled well in the past through courts... they felt that the govt. at the center can do better. If the committee or the present govt. in Kerala has failed in its duty to convey the fear of Kerala, then they should try and do better. I am not of the opinion that the ministers like Anthony from Kerala should behave as cheap as PC Chidamabaram, but they need to come out strong instead of cowering, especially since the state of Kerala always had only one slogan; Safety for Kerala and water for Tamilnadu. Right now, TN farmers are denying vegetable, milk etc to Kerala and also doing much harm to the Keralites residing in the state. There was this scene where they poured milk on the roads while saying that not a drop will go to Kerala even if it is wasted. If this continues, it would be the farmers in TN who will suffer more and the end result would be more hatred towards Kerala. Yes.. the politicians in TN has succeeded in creating fear and hatred in the minds of those in TN. Even now the papers are reporting attacks in Kerala against Tamils where none exists.
It is time the fire is doused before it gets out of control. Yes.. borders are only man made but I am very sure if this dam was in TN, a new dam would have built many years ago.
Even now one is not sure what stops TN from agreeing to a new dam especially since the new dam would be in a site earlier agreed upon by both the states. The old dam can continue to provide water until the new one is ready.
Getting offensive is not the way to solve problems.
Happy Kitten,
on Dec 20, 2011 11:38:46 AM
I hope we would get a solution by February from Supreme court..Building more storage tanks in Tamil nadu and reducing the water level will be an optimum solution for time being.Exixting Dam can be used as diversion point rather than a Storage dam.Technical feasiblity is being discussed.Central govt should be proactive.It is disheartening to see ugly scenes in Chennai and border areas.
Siva C,
on Dec 20, 2011 09:00:21 PM
| News | Features | Columns |
Top Stories
- KOCHU VARTHAMANAM: When Motherhood Comes Calling
- KOCHU VARTHAMANAM: Get Out Of That Skin
- FITNESS TALES: Swimming May Make You Fat
- LIGHTER VEIN: Sherlock Homes & Bike Rider's Ghost
- KOCHU VARTHAMANAM: How Does Your Garden Grow?
- IC 167: This Isn’t Just Social Media
- THIRD EYE: Populism Vs Good Governance: Game Over!
- MONEY MATTERS: Budget Fundas For The Uninitiated
- KOCHU VARTHAMANAM: Found And Lost!
- LIGHTER VEIN: Cats, Dogs And My Neighbour (Part III)
- LIGHTER VEIN: Cats, Dogs And My Neighbour (Part II)
- LIGHTER VEIN: Cats, Dogs And My Neighbour (Part I)
- KOCHU VARTHAMANAM: Random Musings… On A Spot
- THIRD EYE: A Reminder To The Children Of Immortal Bliss!
- FITNESS TALES: PCOD - A Rising Menace
- MONEY MATTERS: 2012 – A Year Of Opportunity For Investors
- KOCHU VARTHAMANAM: A Charmed Year
- LIGHTER VEIN: Preeti, T-Rex And Me (Part Two)
- LIGHTER VEIN: Preeti, T-Rex And Me (Part One)
- FITNESS TALES: THE STRAIGHT ARM LAT PRESS DOWN
- KOCHU VARTHAMANAM: A Lament For A Dying Art
- Reporter's Column: 16th IFFK – Hopelessly Derogated!
- ESSENTIAL ALTERNATIVE: Simple Living!
- THIRD EYE: You Stole Our Hearts…
- MONEY MATTERS: Investor News Roundup




















